A response to Liz Kendall

 Like other Labour members, I yesterday received an email from Liz Kendall. The leadership contest has been uninspiring for me as someone on the ‘realist left’ of the party, and I have not decided my full running order. But at present I won’t be voting for Liz, and even though it probably won’t be read, I thought I owed their team an explanation as to why. Twitter does not bode well, but maybe those of us ideologically closer to the centre of the party will get a listen eventually. Who knows.

I’ve reproduced my response below, in the hope that someone listens, even if it is not her.

Dear Liz Kendall team,

Thus far, your campaign comes across as only caring about one of several groups of people Labour needs to win back. How will you respond to the SNP, who have cost Labour so many seats by attacking us from the left and adding working class voters to the nationalist core vote?

More directly, what do your campaign and your views mean for my residents if we win?

Leaving people with no political choice but further massive cuts would be a big problem for many of the people I represent, meaning that there is no possibility of making a change to the biggest challenge many in the country face. Growth in the real economy is stagnant, and as a country we are currently pulling apart a welfare state that would otherwise provide both a safety net and a ladder up. If we can only win without challenging this, who will?

A stricter immigration system (which I believe you have at least hinted at) would also be very bad news for many of their family lives; indeed I have recently been approached by one resident who has not seen his own wife for over a year because she is already too poor to be allowed to love with him in this, the country of his birth. So many of my residents in Willesden Green were not born as UK nationals. Do they not staff our hospitals, local shops, universities?

This is not just moaning. To me it means something. To hold these points of view may seem like self-indulgence on my part (perhaps a response this long actually is), but I have a duty to represent these people even if their lack of media clout makes them unpopular people – and I am proud to do so.

Finally, I am tired of the leadership debate being carried out in code. If you want to cut more services or capital spending, please please tell us what that means in practice, and give us the chance of a fair choice.

In conclusion, when you are able to explain what your brand of politics offers for aspiring people as well as those who have already made it to comfortability, I promise I will reconsider. 

But for now, I cannot in good conscience give you my support – I am sure you will understand.

Warm regards,

Cllr Miller

Willesden Green Ward


3 thoughts on “A response to Liz Kendall

  1. brendanobrien451

    I’m all in favour of robustly challenging leadership candidates. But why did you select for you website an image of Liz Kendall that is obviously personally unflattering? Did you choose it because it would be funny to make it look as if she is shooting us? It’s not very grown up. All the candidates have said they want to avoid personal attacks and I think that should be good enough for you too.

    1. cllrtommiller Post author

      Hi Brendan,

      I think it’s quite a cool image actually! And this is me saying it. It’s getting a lot of supportive use on Facebook. My reasons were mixed – firstly it’s a really interesting image, and a lot of pictures of politicians are really boring.

      Secondly I didn’t want to be accused of exactly what you’re accusing me of! Or generally not giving a balanced critique. So I used a picture that has generally been used supportively.

  2. Pingback: Corbyn comes to Croydon for free public meeting, Aug 4 | Inside Croydon

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.